Yesterday, I wrote about an initiative, authored by Josie B. and Kent M. Whitney, that would impose additional tax on alcoholic beverages if they collect 433,971 signatures by August 23, 2010, and if a majority of California voters support the measure when they cast their votes on the November 2, 2010 ballot.
The initiative, if successful, would increase the excise tax on distilled spirits 2,703%, on beer 8,255%, and on wine a whopping 12,775%!
The one question being asked across the state is, “Who are Josie B. and Kent M. Whitney, and why are they behind this initiative?”
V Bit Set, an intrepid blogger, looked for answers yesterday, and I have piggybacked on the initial research.
LinkedIn puts Josie Whitney, Owner, Real Estate, in the Greater San Diego Area.
LinkedIn puts Kent Whiney, Owner, 21st Century Wellness Initiative in the Greater San Diego Area.
White Pages directory puts Josie B. Whitney and Kent M. Whitney at 5220 Fiore Terrace, Apt M201, San Diego, CA 92122-5693, (858) 678-8548
Kent is listed as being 69 years old, and in addition to being related to Josephine B. Whitney, is identified as being related to Frances A. Whitney.
Josephine B. Whitney is listed as being 66 years old.
There is a 21st Century Wellness at 23861 El Toro Road, Lake Forest, CA 92630 (949) 900-8262, (949) 462-9761. It is located 64.6 miles miles from the home of Josie B. and Kent M. Whitney. Calls to the first phone number are picked up by an answering service who would not confirm whether Kent whitney was involved with the company. The second number is answered by a different wellness company , New Mecca Wellness.
21st Century Wellness in Lake Forest, CA appears to be the home of Diets Don’t Work, same address, new phone number (800) 711-6336. This phone is also answered by an answering service, and the voice was very similar to the one previously encountered. The phone was answered, “Rebecca’s House, Eating Disorder Treatment Program.” Books, workbooks, online sessions, and DVDs are sold by Rebecca Cooper.
It is not certain that this is the 21st Century Wellness that Kent M. Whitney is the owner of; Rebecca Cooper of Rebecca’s House and Diets Don’t Work lists herself as the CEO of 21st Century Wellness Inc. on her selfgrowth.com biography page.
AgentScoreboard.com puts Josephine Whitney at Independence Realty, 7777 Alvarado Road, Ste 265, La Mesa, CA 91941 (619) 469-9755. Independence Realty is located 15.46 miles from the home of Josie B. and Kent M. Whitney.
Kent M. Whitney of San Diego, CA has 22 Customer Reviews on Amazon.com. One of Kent Whitney’s reviews, of The War by Ken Burns, is signed Master Chief Kent M. Whitney. Kent M. Whitney is very involved with photography.
Most interesting are Kent M. Whitney’s June 7, 2008 Amazon reviews of You: Staying Young: The Owner’s Manual for Extending Your Warranty and YOU: The Owner’s Manual, Updated and Expanded Edition: An Insider’s Guide to the Body that Will Make You Healthier and Younger by Michael Roizen M.D. and Mehmet Oz M.D.; Whitney wrote,
“O.K. Here we are again, another GREAT read by two of the best Doctors in their class. If you want many of the facts in a format that makes sense of it all, then this book is for you. It could very well be the book that adds a few more healthy years to your life. Now that’s a big deal in my point of view. Just think, we just might spend ALL our kids inheritance with the extra time we get on this old planet! Now that is a concept worth thinking about—> PTL Kent, “
and,
“A Kick, great read, pleasant style and full of the things we need to maintain a GREAT and healthy life. Dr Oz & Dr Roizen are in the know and lead their field of Wellness!! PTL Kent.”
The Amazon reviews confirm Kent M. Whitney’s interest in the Wellness field, let us know that Whitney is a serial Lord praiser (PTL is an acronym for Praise The Lord), and claims that he served in either the Navy or Coast Guard long enough to reach the top 1% of his branch’s enlisted force, Master Chief Petty Officer.
These are assertions Josie B. and Kent M. Whitney give for their obscenely huge proposed tax increases:
(a) Alcohol-related problems cost Californians an estimated $38.4 billion annually, including the costs of illness and injury, the criminal justice system, lost productivity, impacts on the welfare system, trauma and emergency care, and the foster care system.
(b) Alcohol use also costs California’s state and county governments approximately $8.3 billion annually in increased health care costs, criminal justice costs, and lost tax revenues, while the income to the state from alcohol licensing, fees, excise taxes, and sales taxes is less than $1 billion annually.
(c) According to the u.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, beer is the most commonly consumed drink by binge drinkers, and 67 percent of binge drinkers are underage. Underage drinkers account for 17.5 percent of all beer consumed annually, spending $22 billion.
(d) Beer accounts for 80 percent of the preferred alcoholic beverages.
(e) Ninety-seven thousand college-age women are raped or sexually assaulted each year under circumstances involving the use of alcohol. Half of all rape victims were intoxicated and half of their attackers were intoxicated at the time of the attack.
(f) Alcohol use during pregnancy causes approximately 5,000 children to be born in California each year with alcohol-related birth defects.
(g) The cost of services for one person born with fetal alcohol syndrome is over $2 million each year.
(h) The use of alcohol is associated with an increased incidence of digestive disease, cancer, neuropsychiatric conditions, cardiovascular disease, malignant neoplasms, pregnancy-related conditions, fetal alcohol syndrome, and high risk sex.
(i) One person dies, and there are 533 incidents of violent crime, every hour due to alcohol use in California.
(j) While the staggering cost of alcohol abuse is borne by all Californians, 67 percent of the alcohol sold in California is consumed by only 11 percent of the population.
(k) The last alcoholic beverage tax increase in California was in 1992.
(l) An alcoholic beverage tax increase is necessary to mitigate the adverse effects of alcohol use.
Josie B. and Kent M. Whitney have provided an even dozen assertions why they wish to levy an increase in excise tax of 12,775% on a bottle of wine. Tom Wark addressed the dirty dozen justifications yesterday in his blog Fermentation.
V Bit Set found a possible stronger motivation:
“One thing that really stood out to me in the proposal was this;
(c) Fifteen percent for the funding of grants for naturopathic treatment and recovery programs for alcohol addiction.
It seems very odd that such a significant amount of grant money would be directed specifically towards naturopathic treatments.”
V Bit Set also uncovered that a Kent Whitney was the LinkedIn self proclaimed owner of 21st Century Wellness Initiative in the Greater San Diego Area.
I do know that finding out more about Kent M. Whitney’s 21st Century Wellness Initiative, what it does, where it is located, is not easy.
I do know that the initiative directs that:
(g) Five percent for programs and public awareness campaigns to prevent the use and abuse of alcoholic beverages. The public awareness campaigns funded under this subdivision shall focus on informing the public, particularly children and young adults, of the potential health risks of alcohol use.
It appears that there may be a financial motive behind the initiative. Josie B. and Kent M. Whitney may be positioning themselves as Wellness alcohol Treatment and Recovery specialists, hoping to cash in a a stream of funding they directed toward themselves through a manipulation of the initiative process.
It is possible that while Kent is not praising the Lord, he is ignoring Christ’s first miracle turning water to wine, and Christ’s exhortations, “to take this cup, all of you, and drink it.” Wine is an important part of my culture, and my brand of Christianity. Kent’s brand of Christianity seems to be heavy on the lip, but light on the service. He is more akin to the money changers, and he should be cast out from the church. I can’t swear for sure, but it is possible that Kent is a hypocrite, and hates God, and all his good works.
I do know that Josie and Kent are neo-prohibitionists. I thought it likely, but the words from their own initiative, “Five percent for programs and…campaigns to prevent the use…of alcoholic beverages.”
The state’s analysis forecasts a loss of hundreds of millions of dollars in tax revenue if this initiative becomes law. Jobs will be lost. Businesses will close. Millennia of wine and food culture, the healthful benefits of responsible wine enjoyment, the traditions of Christ’s church all ignored.
This seems like a myopic possible money grab, at the expense of state revenue, and an anti-alcohol initiative, disguised as a tax increase, authored by the kind of Christian that makes real Christians embarrassed. Having said that, sometimes appearances are deceiving, and I look forward to interviews of Josie B. and Kent M. Whitney.
This will continue.
April 1, 2010 at 2:13 PM
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by unravel101: Yesterday, I wrote about the 12,775% wine tax increase California ballot initiative; today, I look at the authors: http://bit.ly/d1HHFx [...]
April 2, 2010 at 4:43 PM
This is a totally regressive tax based initiative. It must be stopped from going any further. Should this reach the November ballot, it will be soundly defeated, but what a waste of taxpayer money to even have it qualified and placed on the ballot.
April 2, 2010 at 4:55 PM
All “flat taxes” are by definition regressive. This is not only a flat tax, but an obscene one.
Bernie, I could not agree more, the potential waste of money is appalling. I believe that snow balls in Hell have a better shot than this does of passing; but if you had told me 10 years ago that Arnold Schwarzenegger would one day become my Governor, I would have thought you insane.
Thanks for reading, and thanks for leaving a comment.
John
April 3, 2010 at 5:45 AM
This infuriated me when I read this. I think the average citizen will not vote for this initiative. These people better not ask me to sign their ballot either because I don’t know if I would be able to control myself.
April 3, 2010 at 12:28 PM
1. Don’t sign the petition.
2. Tell the signature collector that you know friends and family members who work n the wine industry, and would likely lose their jobs if this made it onto the ballot and was passed; then ask them if they can put it on the bottom of the pile of initiatives they are collecting signatures for.
3. Tell your friends about this, feel free to send them a link to my site.
4. Most importantly, if this makes it onto the November ballot, vote against it.
Thanks for your support.
John
April 3, 2010 at 6:11 AM
I understand your disdain with the tax increase, but your comments regarding Christianity caused me to lose what little respect that I could muster for your entry. Water into wine aside, I find it wholly quixotic to presume Jesus’ message was to spread tax-free wine to all of his deserving constituents. Nothing in the increased tax proposal states you are not entitled to your alcoholic cravings. Your appeal to Religion is nothing short of trite drivel. Jesus brought a message of love, not a message of the right to drink tax free.
April 3, 2010 at 12:24 PM
Thank you for your comment. I am grateful that you took the time to leave it. I welcome view points other than my own. Together, all of our contributions make this a better forum for understanding.
I do not condemn Christianity, I condemn fundie faux-Christian hypocrites, who say one thing but do the opposite. I would lump Kent M. Whitney in with Pat Robertson, Jerry Falwell, and Fred Phelps who I see as Christians of convenience, but hypocrites of habit. While not as famous as the others, Whitney is, in my opinion, just as guilty of pretending to be a Christian, “Praise The Lord,” he is engaged in a neo-prohibitionist attack on the use, not just abuse, of all alcohol, including wine.
Christ turned water to wine, the Christian church I was raised in celebrates Christ through another miracle involving wine, Transubstantiation. Christ wanted us to enjoy wine. Kent. M Whitney was to prevent us from enjoying wine, and has masked his attack as a tax increase. While a reasonable increase of say 5-10% might have been considered reasonable, perhaps feasible, a 12,775% tax increase is clearly meant as a means to prevent wine consumption. It is an attack on what might be considered the most Christian of beverages.
A quick note; you mischaracterize my enjoyment of wine as “alcoholic cravings.” I do not drink alcohol every day, and I do not binge drink alcohol. I do not feel an alcoholic’s cravings, or need, to drink alcohol. I enjoy wine with food, I cook with it and I pair it with the food I cook for my family and friends. Wine is food. My last name is Cesano, I was raised in an Italian household; wine has been a part of Italian culture in Italy for Millennia, and it was Italian Americans who are responsible for premium dry wine in America. We follow Christ’s example and use wine in our celebrations, and we follow his instructions and use wine in our church services.
Look, I’ll admit that I could have attacked the initiative on the merits alone, but Kent M. Whitney is the author and in looking into his possible motivations for writing the initiative I found he cloaks himself in what is universally understood to be an expression of Christian faith. Everything about the Whitney initiative is a direct assault on Christ’s beverage, church services that bring Christians closer to Christ, and an entire culture that celebrates both Christ and wine. Let me be clear, I am pro-Christianity; but I abhor people who say things like, “Praise The Lord,” while acting in a grossly unChristian way.
The Christian church I was raised in is involved of acts of charity, motivated by God’s love for all his children. Kent M. Whitney seems more interested in swelling the ranks of the unemployed through his heartlessly un-Christian initiative. Although Christ told us to love the poor, I am reasonably confident that he didn’t intend that we should author initiatives that would, if passed, transform many hardworking people into unemployed poor people.
I love Christians, but I am not a fan of religion, and I abhor fundie faux-Christian hypocrites. I suspect from his words and actions that Kent M. Whitney is one. I am far more confident that Falwell, Robetson, and Phelps are:
“AIDS is not just God’s punishment for homosexuals; it is God’s punishment for the society that tolerates homosexuals,”
“I hope to see the day when we wont have any public schools. What a happy day that will be!”
“Christians, like slaves and soldiers, ask no questions.”
– Jerry Falwell
“I know this is painful for the ladies to hear, but if you get married, you have accepted the headship of a man, your husband. Christ is the head of the household and the husband is the head of the wife, and that’s the way it is, period.”
“I don’t know about this doctrine of assassination, but if he thinks we’re trying to assassinate him, I think that we really ought to go ahead and do it.”
“It has happened because God Almighty is lifting His protection from us.” (September 13, 2001, in explanation of the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001)
“It may be a blessing in disguise. … Something happened a long time ago in Haiti, and people might not want to talk about it. Haitians were originally under the heel of the French. You know, Napoleon the third, or whatever. And they got together and swore a pact to the devil. They said, we will serve you if you will get us free from the French. True story. And so, the devil said, okay it’s a deal. Ever since they have been cursed by one thing after the other.” (explanation on the earthquake in Haiti on January 13, 2010)
-Pat Robertson
“You can’t preach the Bible without preaching hatred.”
“God doesn’t hate them because they’re fags; they’re fags because God hates them.”
“Well, that’s to bad, isn’t it? They think I can’t preach at times like this? I think I can preach at times like this.”
Signs carried at Westboro Baptist Church events include, “Thank God for Dead Soldiers,” “God Hates Your Tears,” and “Pray For More Dead Kids.”
-Fred Phelps (Founding pastor of the Westboro Baptist Church who leads his followers to highly visible protests held at the funeral services of US military personnel killed in action in the Middle East)
I imagine you weren’t expecting me to publish your comment, or that your comment would allow me to expand on what was a minor and undeveloped portion of my initial post. Thank you for the opportunity you gave me, and you are welcome to return with a reasoned defense of Whitney, Falwell, Robertson and Phelps if such a thing is possible. Alternately, you can join me in condemning the hypocrisy of pretending to be a Christian while trying to use politics to force people away from Christ’s example and instruction regarding wine.
Your mischaracterization regarding my non-existent cavings, and odd suggestion that I appealed to religion, make me think that you might share the many of the same motivations, feelings, and sentiments that were behind this initiative. My readership is made up largely of wine and food enthusiasts, and the support of this series of articles has been almost uniformly positive, overwhelmingly so on facebook and email messages. I don’t know you, but I welcome you back to explain yourself more fully, perhaps more honestly. As you claim “little respect”, and that had to be “muster”ed, for my entry before my comments regarding what I described as the un-Christian tone of the initiative in the face of the author’s suggested Christianity, which is a completely different thing than “comments regarding Christianity;” I hope you appreciate the kind welcome and consideration I have given your comment.
DISCLOSURE: I am a terribly lapsed Catholic. I have several friends who I envy their faith. I try to do right, and do so without fear of eternal punishment or everlasting reward, which I think makes my choices to be good all the more noble. That said, I have one particular friend who demonstrates with his entire existence the very best aspects of Christianity. I was a practicing, believing Christian. I think Christianity can be an incredible force for good. While not a fan of religion, I am not anti-religion.
April 16, 2010 at 2:27 PM
Good article John but I’m going to hunt down the petition gatherers and sign along with encouraging every voter I know to do the same. I mean, read the reasons alcohol ravages our society. If the CDC says that 87,000 women are raped every year because of alcohol … who are we to dispute the CDC? The evil wine grower baron s MUST PAY! Not only that I’d support requiring a breathalyser ignition lock with every six-pack of Bud and while we’re at it let’s demand that the Clydedales be ground into dog food!
Appalled yet? You should be and should have. The rhetoric these wellness hacks quote are awfully similar to Rob Reiner and his blue nosed twits years ago. Who amongst us can dispute that the evil, filthy, diseased smokers deserve to pay for all the death and destruction caused by the devil weed.
Maybe you should read the poem or youtube video , “The Hangman” by Maurice Ogden.
First the unclean smokers, then the nasty wine drinkers….. I did no more than what you let me do.
Who’s next for the Steuer-Mann schlinge? You’ve the found the answer in a mirror.
April 19, 2010 at 4:24 PM
Paul, what a great comment. Thank you for leaving it. I was imagining the likely talking points that the initiative’s proponents would be using this fall, so when I read your purposefully over the top, wonderfully sarcastic words I was glad to find that I am not the only one who sees that these folks have succeeded in the past and must be stopped now.
I see the argument focusing on the few most irresponsible members of society instead of the vast majority of healthy responsible alcohol consumers. I see the argument focusing on the big money global conglomerates and alcohol distributers instead of the fourth generation grape grower or family winemaker. I see the same divide and conquer, the same user should pay the cost, argument to justify this obscene tax increase initiative.
Thanks for stopping by, I appreciate it.
John
May 30, 2010 at 8:47 AM
[...] an interestingly blog post regarding this issue and its backers here. I really hate “do-gooders” like this who feel it is their fucking mission in life to [...]